Sunday, May 7, 2023

The Big Bang is funny on so many levels

OK. I'll admit it. I like the TV show, The Big Bang Theory. If you can look past the gratuitous sex, the frequent jabs at religion, and the ubiquitous, dysfunctional parent/child relationships, it's really funny. It's a show written by nerds, about nerds, and for nerds. Recently, I was watching some short clips from the show on YouTube and came across this knee-slapper.

It's funny on so many levels. Of course, it's funny for the obvious reason – the intended punchline of the joke. However, I saw something else humorous in it that likely wasn't intended:


In the debate on origins, the question often comes down to the ultimate origin of matter. Where did everything come from? The Big Bang theory (the scientific theory – not the TV show) has no explanation for the origin of matter. It merely proposes that all matter once existed in a single point without explaining where the matter came from. Such an explanation can't quite satisfy the curious mind. Merely assuming the existence of matter is no more scientific than saying, “God did it.”


Consistent with their “natural-only” worldview, some people suggest a quantum origin of matter. They would have us believe that matter literally poofed into existence. It wasn't caused or created. It just became – without purpose or design.


I think the people who propose such an incredible “non-cause” for the origin of matter are seldom in earnest. They simply have nothing else to which they can resort. Could it be that naturalists hope people will be so intimidated by the weighty, scientific principles of quantum physics that they won't see the absurdity of believing the universe just poofed into existence?


Penny's joke was funny because the physicist believed the odds of a pretty girl poofing into existence in one quantum leap is more likely than a real girl being interested in him. In the real world, secular scientists believe that the universe poofing itself into existence sounds more credible and likely than the purposeful design of an omnipotent Creator.


I can't decide which is funnier, the show or the theory.  At least the show is trying to be funny.

Sunday, April 16, 2023

Peppered moth "evolution"?

One of the lies told by evolutionists is that microevolution over time leads to macroevolution.  Berkeley.edu explains it this way:

Microevolutionary change might seem too unimportant to account for such amazing evolutionary transitions as the origin of dinosaurs or the radiation of land plants — however, it is not. Microevolution happens on a small time scale — from one generation to the next. When such small changes build up over the course of millions of years, they translate into evolution on a grand scale — in other words, macroevolution!


The peppered moth is perhaps the most famous example of “microevolution.” You may recall studying the peppered moth in highschool biology. It’s considered a textbook example of evolution via natural selection.  In case you don’t remember, let me briefly recap what has been claimed of the peppered moth.


The peppered moth is a species of moth in England that come in varieties of light and dark. Prior to the industrial revolution, the population of moths was mostly (approximately 98%) light.  They matched the lichen on trees and it was believed their light color helped camouflage them from being seen and eaten by birds.  


When the industrial revolution began, soot from the factories settled on the trees and killed the lichens.  Now, the darker variety of moth was better camouflaged against trees and the lighter moths were seen and eaten more by birds.  Over a few years, the population became mostly dark moths.


Eventually, factories became cleaner, the soot was cleaned up, and the lichen returned to the trees.  Consequently, the population of moths eventually returned to being mostly light.  


While this might fit the technical definition of evolution, I think it could be the worst example of evolution I’ve ever seen.  Let me explain.  As I’ve said, evolutionists tend to conflate micro- and macroevolution. Regarding the peppered moth Bionity.com said this:


Critics have pointed out that the "peppered moth story" showed only microevolution, rather than the important macroevolutionary trend of speciation…  Biologists agree with this point, and accept that correlation between soot on tree trunks and observed melanism in the moths is not proof of the theory of evolution as a whole. However, many do not accept the supposed distinction between "microevolution" and "macroevolution" as being part of the modern evolutionary synthesis which equates the two, instead taking the view that the mechanisms of microevolution and macroevolution are the same, the only difference being of time and scale.


You can see that the clear implication is that microevolution + time = macroevolution. The tiny changes (microevolution), like we saw in the peppered moth, over long periods of time, will lead to larger changes (macroevolution) in the species. So here's the question: It's been more than a century since the peppered moth study. What "macroevolution" has occurred? Now, I know what you're going to say. 100 years isn't enough time. But think very carefully and tell me this: what "microevolution" has occurred in the last 100 years? Don't think too hard because I'm going to tell you. None. The ratio of light/dark moths has changed back and forth to a net change of ZERO! There was not even microevolution!  The change is not accumulating nor can it. If birds continuously ate one color of moth, it will never add new colors to the population no matter how long it occurs.


Let me be clear: evolution does not occur at all - neither micro nor macro.  For evolution to occur, traits must be added to a population. For a dino to become a bird, for example, you need to add feathers. Natural selection removes traits from a population. Birds eating one shade of moth is an example of natural selection and demonstrates one way traits could be removed. Therefore, natural selection is the opposite of evolution. The “little” changes we observe in populations (the removal of traits or the rearranging of existing traits) will never amount to anything. It would be wrong to call them microevolution. 


Evolutionists give no consideration to the types of changes we observe. By their own admission, the only difference they see between micro- and macroevolution is time and scale. They believe the same mechanisms drive both and the accumulations of small changes (micro) will amount to big changes (macro) over time. That’s like believing you could turn a molehill into a mountain by continuously removing dirt; you just have to dig long enough!

Sunday, April 9, 2023

The Bema Seat of Christ


For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ; that every one may receive the things done in his body, according to that he hath done, whether it be good or bad. 2 Corinthians 5:10

The Bible tells us that there will be a time when believers will stand before Christ and have their works judged.  We’re not judged for our salvation but for a reward.  1 Corinthians 3:10-15 describes this judgment as a trial by fire which will reveal the sort of works we’ve done.  Our worldly pursuits will be burned away like wood, hay, and stubble.  Only the things we did for the Kingdom will remain, revealed by the fire and made pure like gold, silver, and precious stones.  What remains after the judgment will be our reward.  It’s sobering to know that the things I do now have eternal consequences.  It would be to my shame if I stood there empty handed while other saints cast their crowns at Jesus’ feet!


The word translated in the Bible as “judgment seat” is the Greek word, bēma (βῆμα, Strong’s word 968).  A while back, I did a search to see how many times the word βήμα is used in the Bible. It is used 10 times (in various forms): 8 times in the epistles and twice in the gospels. The two times it is used in the gospels (Matthew 27:19 and John 19:13), it refers to the same event which is the judgment of Jesus before Pilate.


Here is the account from Matthew in context (Matthew 27:19-24):


When he was set down on the judgment seat, his wife sent unto him, saying, Have thou nothing to do with that just man: for I have suffered many things this day in a dream because of him. But the chief priests and elders persuaded the multitude that they should ask Barabbas, and destroy Jesus. The governor answered and said unto them, Whether of the twain will ye that I release unto you? They said, Barabbas. Pilate saith unto them, What shall I do then with Jesus which is called Christ? They all say unto him, Let him be crucified. And the governor said, Why, what evil hath he done? But they cried out the more, saying, Let him be crucified. When Pilate saw that he could prevail nothing, but that rather a tumult was made, he took water, and washed his hands before the multitude, saying, I am innocent of the blood of this just person: see ye to it.


I thought it was interesting that Jesus Himself was once judged before the Bema seat. We know the outcome, of course; He was ultimately sentenced to be crucified. However, note carefully what Pilate said about Him. He said that Jesus was a “just person” who had done no evil. In John 19:6, Pilate is quoted as saying, “I find no fault in him at all.” The accusation board Pilate wrote to be placed over Jesus said only that He was “King of the Jews.” Was that the worst that could be said about Him? Pilate might as well have written, “Savior of the world.”


It's significant that Jesus was found to be without guilt. The Bible says that the wages of sin is death (Romans 6:23). If Jesus had been guilty of any sin, He would have been deserving of death. If He had been deserving of death, He could not have given His life as the payment for our sins since He would have had to die for His own sins. But He was innocent. He was the lamb without blemish – the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world!


Before we stand before the Judgment Seat, it was necessary for Him to stand before the judgment seat. It is by His obedience that we are made righteous (Romans 5:19). Praise God!!

Wednesday, March 1, 2023

Creationism isn't the problem


There’s an oft repeated claim that, if kids are taught creation, they won’t be able to understand science.  Bill Nye has made this very point. In his own words, he claimed the following (
source):

[T]here are more people in the world — another billion people all trying to use the world’s resources. And the threat and consequences of climate change are more serious than ever, so we need as many people engaged in how we’re going to deal with that as possible. And we have an increasingly technologically sophisticated society. We are able to feed these 7.2 billion people because of our extraordinary agricultural technology. If we have a society that’s increasingly dependent on these technologies, with a smaller and smaller fraction of that society who actually understands how any of it works, that is a formula for disaster.... My biggest concern about creationist kids is that they’re compelled to suppress their common sense, to suppress their critical thinking skills at a time in human history when we need them more than ever.... There are just things about evolution that we should all be aware of, the way we’re aware of where electricity comes from.


Nye certainly paints a bleak picture. We live in a world, supposedly becoming overcrowded, where billions of people have to compete for limited resources. We need new technologies. We need alternative sources of fuel – cleaner burning fuel. We need new medicines. We need science! But if kids are being taught creation, they won't be able to contribute anything to science. We're losing our best resource – the potential of the next generation – at a time “when we need them more than ever!” 


Huh?


There are several things wrong with statements like this. First, it's a tangle of logical fallacies. Let's see... it's non sequitur in the sense that there's no link between believing creation and understanding technology. What, I can't use a computer because I'm a creationist? There is nothing that connects understanding science to understanding evolution.  Can anyone name even one invention in the last century that hinged upon evolution being true?  Life improving technologies - made by real scientists - are made every day without a single thought being given to evolution.  Nye thinks we need to understand evolution just like we understand electricity.  Why?  Electricity is fundamental to our everyday existence.  Evolution is the trivial pursuit branch of science!  


The claim that students can’t understand science unless they believe evolution is also an example of a No True Scotsman argument.  Think about it.  It invents a qualifier for understanding science – that is, “everyone who truly understands science believes evolution.” Major fields of science were founded by people who believed in creation.  I could provide quotes from people like Newton, Mendel, or Kepler that show they believed in a Divine Creator but that’s not necessary because I’m not saying that creation is true because people like Newton believed in a Creator. I'm saying that their belief in a Creator did not affect their ability to make contributions to science or invent life improving technologies.


Finally, it's an appeal to consequences.  Nye would have us believe that students who believe creation can’t understand science.  Even assuming that were correct, how would that prove that evolution is true or that creation is false?  It would do neither.  It’s simply a gimmick that asserts, “bad things will happen if you believe this so don’t believe it!”  It’s not evidence for anything - it’s simply a fear tactic.  That’s why we call it a fallacy.


But besides its weak philosophical footing,  I don't believe Nye, or anyone else, can even establish a causal link between believing creation and lower academic performance.  If somebody knows of some scientific survey showing this, I would love to see it because, to this day, I've seen nothing – not one thing – that evolutionists can point to that supports their assertion. It's a tired scare tactic used by evolutionists to claim that kids can't understand science if they believe creation yet they have nothing beyond their flapping gums to support this claim. In fact, a case could be made for the opposite; kids who are home-schooled or who attend private, Christian schools – places where creation is more likely to be taught – generally perform better on standardized tests than kids in public schools where creation is not taught.creation) tend to outperform public school students (where only evolution is taught). 


Look, if Nye really wants to better prepare kids to contribute to society, evolution would be very low on the list of where education needs improvement. According to Wikipedia, 54% of adults in the United States have prose literacy below the 6th-grade level.  Here’s a video you might find interesting.




I've seen dozens of videos just like this one – videos where kids can't answer basic questions about science or politics or geography or history. If evolutionists were truly worried about preparing kids for the future, they would be alarmed that these young people don’t know how many dimes make a dollar!  But no, they think we need to devote more energy and resources to teaching them evolution! I truly believe they are more interested in indoctrinating kids rather than educating them.

Thursday, February 23, 2023

“Kind” versus “species”

The term “species” is surprisingly difficult to define. When asked, most people offer a reproductive test; that is, creatures that can reproduce naturally together and have fertile offspring are the same species. Of course, this definition is not without a myriad of exceptions. Wolves and dogs, for example, can mate and have fertile offspring yet they are considered different species. So can bison and cows, polar and grizzly bears, and dozens of other mammals. Hybridization is ridiculously common in plants. All of these are examples of different species mating so the ability to reproduce is not a rigorous definition of a species. Neither can a reproductive test be used to identify species of asexual organisms like bacteria or viruses.

Species is an invented term, I understand that. And, in spite of the many problems of defining it, I usually don't have a problem with the word. However, in some cases, an exact meaning of the term is necessary.  For example, I came across an article a while back that claimed, “Scientists are watching a new species of birds evolve in real time.” Here is an excerpt from the article:


A new finch species has been observed evolving in the space of just two generations, challenging the general consensus that evolution is a slow process involving hundreds of thousands of years.


You can see that the article gives us the impression that speciation is an example of evolution.  So if the rise of a new species is to be used as an example of evolution, then yes, I'm going to ask what criteria are scientists using to define a species? 


It's typical of evolutionists to make the straw man argument that creationists deny speciation.  The reality is that most creationists don't deny speciation. In fact, it's a critical part of young earth creationism. God created animals according to “kinds.” Noah took terrestrial animals on the ark in pairs of “kinds.” All modern species are descended from these narrow groups. The 30+ species of modern cats are all descended from the 2 felines on the ark, for example.


When told that creationists accept speciation, evolutionists respond in one of two ways. One way is to ridicule the creation model as a type of “hyper-evolution” because the amount of diversification that has occurred during the time since the Flood is much faster than the slow, gradual process theorized by evolutionists.  It's also somewhat hypocritical of them to criticize creationists for believing in rapid speciation when they post articles like the one above talking about speciation happening before their eyes.


Before I get to the second point, let me clear up a few things about this article.  What is being discussed in the article is an example of hybridization, which, as I’ve already discussed above, is rather ordinary.  It’s certainly not the first time we’ve observed it!  Furthermore, this is a rather old story that is constantly trotted out every couple of years as though it’s news!  The above article was published on 4/1/2022 (maybe it was meant to be an April Fool’s Joke?) but it’s just a rehash of the same story I found published by RT.com 11/24/2017.  But Wired published an even older version 11/16/2009.  You would think that, if evolution were true, they wouldn’t have to keep using the same example over and over as evidence for their theory!


Having cleared that up, let me get to my second point.  The other way evolutionists respond when creationists ask for a definition of the word species, is to throw out a red herring and ask the creationist to define the term, kind. It's a red herring because, whether or not a creationist can define the word, kind, it doesn't excuse evolutionists from having to define species when it's being used in the example above.


One time, when I was debating some evolutionists on social media, one critic actually said he couldn't respond to any of my points until I gave a precise definition of kind. Really? I doubt that. I mean, there may not be an iron clad definition of the word species but I understand the term well enough to discuss it. I use the term frequently myself and only ask for a rigorous definition when evolutionists try to leverage speciation as evidence for their theory. Am I supposed to believe that evolutionists can't understand the concept of kind well enough to discuss it unless we give them an iron clad definition first? Like I said, it's a red herring.


I've discussed species and kinds on my blog before. I might not be able to give a rigorous definition of either but here are some practical definitions. I've always favored using morphology to identify a species. Once a population has enough traits in common that they can all be identified as belonging to the same group, then they earn the moniker of species. Thus bears with large bodies, white fur, long necks, and pointed faces are polar bears; bears with smaller bodies, brown fur, short necks, and shovel-shaped faces are grizzly bears. Admittedly that definition has its own difficulties but at least it acknowledges the fact that identifying a species is more subjective than objective. It also dispels the mistaken impression that species are absolutely distinct and don't reproduce together. A kind, on the other hand, is a group of organisms originally created by God that would reproduce organisms similar to themselves and includes all the varied species descended from the original group. 


Think about examples of species and kinds. Dogs, wolves, and coyotes can breed together and have fertile offspring yet they are considered different species. Because of their very different anatomies, Great Danes can no longer reproduce with chihuahuas yet they are still considered the same species.  Evolutionists and creationists both agree that all canines have descended from a common ancestor yet if creationists call the members of the canine group a “kind,” evolutionists act like they can't understand the term at all. //RKBentley scratches his head//


Evolutionists play word games. They constantly conflate natural selection and evolution. I’ve talked before (here) about how they casually use the word theory but harp on creationists for calling evolution a theory. They claim macroevolution is evolution above the species level but they can't even define what a species is. When pressed for a definition of species, they attempt to derail the conversation by asking creationists to define a kind instead. I agree you can't have a conversation with someone if there isn't a clear understanding of the terms being discussed. In the evolution/creation debate, evolutionists aren't interested in discussion. I know they're not stupid – they're just playing dumb. Conflate, equivocate, obfuscate. That's the tactic of evolutionists.